Morone’s Italian Villa

Reviews

• Michael P.

  star star star star star 2 June 2026

  First time today!  Always wanted to try it.  Had " " The Ray" with fries,  House salad and angel hair with Alfredo.  Very reasonable price, friendly on the phone and friendly when we picked up the food.  Very clean inside with a cozy, neighborhood Italian restaurant look and feel.  Good was great!  This is a good place and we will be back!  Need to try some pizza and more pasta .

• Carey R.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 1 June 2026

  Went in because I was craving lasagna and it was close. My boyfriend saw a heavy set woman prepping food in the kitchen with no hair net and no gloves. He spoke with the owner who told him she doesn't need gloves to prep food that is getting ready to be cooked. He didn't disagree. But when he addressed the hair net she told us to go ahead and leave. So we did.
  
  We know she knew better. The two guys working in the kitchen had on ball caps.
  
  THIS IS BEING REPORTED TO THE HEALTH DEPARTMENT.

• Alexis R.

  star star star star_border star_border 30 May 2026

  Tried Morone's today. It was fine... part of the problem was likely that I ordered online. I've been wanting to try them because their menu says they do four different types of crust! I ordered two personal size pizzas: one Pan style (thick) and the other Pie style (thicker hand tossed). The app had me specify what type of crust I wanted... but then they both came super thin? ‍ So I'm not sure what went wrong... perhaps you can't make the personal pizzas a special type of crust? Or, maybe they didn't read the yelp order thoroughly? Bottom line- I suggest ordering by phone! NOT through online. Also- I made no attempt to go back into the restaurant to "fix" my order, so that's on me.
  
  The flavor was really good overall, good cheese, couldn't really taste the sauce (which again it had 4 different sauces you could pick from), crust was very thin, but floppy (which I don't mind), but was just looking for something thicker. Pepperoni were yummy!

• Tiffany R.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 23 May 2026

  ***This review is wholly based on the phone call we had with the staff there.
  
  We are planning our holiday party and they did not have information on the website. It's states to call to get information which is what I did. I called and asked if they could give me more information on pricing and if they had a private room to hold a holiday party for my employees. I was put on hold, but instead of actually putting me hold she just put the phone down and yelled to someone "She wants to know about parties or something like that", with an attitude. As if I was disturbing them.
  
  When she got back on the phone so still acted as if I was bothering her. When I asked about prices, she just kept saying it depends on what you order. She couldn't give me any information. I asked if the menu was the same as the one online and her response was to just come in.
  
  Don't advertise group events and buffets and tell your customers to call for more information on your website if you don't want them to call and ask. If this is how you treat people who haven't even come there, why would I want to?
  
  I hope one day I am able to change this review, but as of now I will never step foot in this restaurant.

• Javier V.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 15 May 2026

  First impressions count and I haven't even tasted their food, but based on the rude phone reception on a carry out order placed, would NEVER go back. Even after they screwed up our order, we called back to express our concerns and they could have cared less. Way too many pizza joints in Columbus, and even if their pizza impresses in taste, will not be a returning customer.